PB&J Pie

This is my third and final post for Project PB&J – a blogger cooking contest for National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day. Check out some of the other recipes for Project PB&J here!

Have you ever had something you couldn’t wait to get home and create? That was my sentiment when thinking about this pie.

I had been working up what I wanted my final entry into project pb&j to be. The strawberries in my fridge were calling my name.

The thought of a pb&j pie floated around my head. Sounds good..but how to put it together?

pie 3 PB&J Pie

Peanut butter crust and fruity, jammy filling…why not!

Since I made this before my fluff, I poured that on top when it was fresh (and pourable). Viola! Fluffernutter pie! Fluff not necessary, but very very delicious.

This pie can easily be replicated with your favorite nut butter in the crust and what ever fruit you have available.

slice of pie1 PB&J Pie

PB&J Pie


  • 1/2 cup butter, at room temperature
  • 1/2 cup peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 1/4 cups flour
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1 1/2 lbs strawberries
  • 2 tbsp sugar
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • 1/2 packet gelatin

To Make the Pie:

  1. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
  2. In the bowl of your stand mixer paddle the butter until smooth and soft. Add the peanut butter and brown sugar. Mix on medium speed until light and fluffy. Scrape the bowl.
  3. Mix in the egg until just incorporated. Then with the mixer on low speed add the flour and salt. Mix until fully combined.
  4. Press the crust into an even layer in your pie pan. Note: this is a lot like cookie dough, but don’t be afraid to mold it to your pie plate! You want a nice thick cookie dough crust.
  5. Once the oven is preheated bake the crust for 15 minutes, or until it is lightly golden and puffy.
  6. While the crust is baking slice half of the strawberries, and roughly chop the other half. Blend/puree the strawberries, sugar, and vanilla to a smooth puree. Pour into a small saucepan and stir in the gelatin over medium-low heat until the gelatin has dissolved.
  7. When the crust is done allow it to cool for 5 minutes then arrange the sliced strawberries on it. Pour the strawberry puree over the strawberries and crust. Bake for 15-20 minutes, or the until the crust has browned and the fruit has softened. Cool before serving.

 So which of my 3 Project PB&J recipes do you like best?

fluffernutter 150x150 PB&J Pie   baked creme brulee 150x150 PB&J Pie   pie 2 150x150 PB&J Pie

The Fluffernutter? The PB&J Creme Brûlée? Or the Pie?

PBJfinal copy PB&J Pie

About bigfatbaker

BigFatBaker is written by Erin Meyer. Erin is a college student looking to learn more about the kitchen through her various baking adventures. Check out the about page for more information!


  1. this pie looks so awesome! PB & J anything is awesome, but a pie…oh boy!

  2. I think you completely rocked the challenge with this recipe. Great idea. It looks amazing!

  3. PB&J pie all the way. I love the idea.

  4. Yes yes please! Love PB&J!!

  5. Wow, you are really kicking pb&j butt! :)

  6. Wow, Erin, you did it agian. This looks amazing. I’m a pb fanatic, and I’ve been addicted to your blog all week. Everything you’ve made looks delicious.

    • bigfatbaker says:

      Thanks Jennie! I think this was the mine and the BF’s favorite for the week. So easy and it kept decently well.

  7. I’m in love with all the PBJ on this blog. It’s like a childhood dream come true.

  8. What a wonderful sweet treat. I love anything PB &J Thanks for sharing with us.

  9. What a gorgeous pie – pbj anything is my definition of heaven :D
    And staring at your pics is taking me there fast!

    Choc Chip Uru
    Latest: Maple Raisin Ice Cream

  10. Another incredible PB&J creation!

  11. I don’t like the PB projects your working on, I must have them all!!! Please send to me all of your creations!!!

  12. Your pie sounds delicious! I love pb&j anything, but this is a wonderful way to use the combo!

  13. this looks wonderful

  14. Oh my gosh this looks DELICIOUS!!!

  15. What a gorgeous idea To use the fresh strawberries, it looks wonderful:-) Hugs, Terra

  16. With a pound and a half of strawberries, it’s got to be healthy, right!?!?!? :D

  17. This is a fabulous idea for a pie! It looks so yummy!

  18. pb&j pie totally beats out the sandwich I have waiting for me to lunch tomorrow haha. looks divine Erin! thanks for sharing.

  19. Woah! Loving this PBJ Project. What a wonderful pie!

  20. Ap-pie-tizing! ;)

    “Happy Cooking”


  1. Project PB&J says:

    [...] PB&J Pie from Big Fat Baker [...]

Speak Your Mind